Talk:Internationalization/file format - Revision history

Trosim: /* PO vs. XML? */

2006-05-03T17:51:58Z

‎PO vs. XML?

2006-05-03T17:35:02Z

‎PO vs. XML?

2006-05-03T17:34:34Z

‎PO vs. XML?

2006-05-03T17:34:16Z

‎PO vs. XML?

2006-05-03T17:31:48Z

‎Comments

2006-05-02T21:02:46Z

‎Voting

2006-05-02T21:01:03Z

style changes

2006-05-02T20:57:02Z

‎Voting: fix total

2006-05-02T20:45:50Z

‎Voting

2006-05-02T20:43:03Z

‎Voting

@@ Line 29: / Line 29: @@
 The two possibilities "can" the same things, so I think that we should concentrate on the practical work.
 Would you like to write a parser for PO or some tools that can save in XML too?
-If, as a group, we answer "A parser for PO!", than I completly agree. [[User:Trosim|Trosim]]
+If, as a group, we answer "A parser for PO!", than I completly agree, even if the drawbacks pointed out on the article page are not persuasive at all. [[User:Trosim|Trosim]]
 ==Partiality, unicode and readability==

@@ Line 29: / Line 29: @@
 The two possibilities "can" the same things, so I think that we should concentrate on the practical work.
 Would you like to write a parser for PO or some tools that can save in XML too?
-If, as a group, we answer "A parser for PO!", than I completly agree.
+If, as a group, we answer "A parser for PO!", than I completly agree. [[User:Trosim|Trosim]]
 ==Partiality, unicode and readability==

@@ Line 17: / Line 17: @@
 No, that's not a war, that's a practical matter.
 I would like to be a little bit more precise on the advantages/drawbacks of the two formats:
@@ Line 29: / Line 28: @@
 The two possibilities "can" the same things, so I think that we should concentrate on the practical work.
 Would you like to write a parser for PO or some tools that can save in XML too?
 If, as a group, we answer "A parser for PO!", than I completly agree.

@@ Line 17: / Line 17: @@
 No, that's not a war, that's a practical matter.
 I would like to be a little bit more precise on the advantages/drawbacks of the two formats:
@@ Line 31: / Line 32: @@
 Would you like to write a parser for PO or some tools that can save in XML too?
 ==Partiality, unicode and readability==

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:31, 3 May 2006
Line 13:		Line 13:

	So, as you can see I found few positive aspects for XML and few negative for PO. I don't want to advertise the PO format, so if you know/find aspects that I haven't mentioned, don't hesitate to add them! [[User:Etienner\|Etienner]] 17:09, 28 April 2006 (CEST)		So, as you can see I found few positive aspects for XML and few negative for PO. I don't want to advertise the PO format, so if you know/find aspects that I haven't mentioned, don't hesitate to add them! [[User:Etienner\|Etienner]] 17:09, 28 April 2006 (CEST)
		+
		+	==PO vs. XML?==
		+
		+	No, that's not a war, that's a practical matter.
		+	I would like to be a little bit more precise on the advantages/drawbacks of the two formats:
		+
		+	PO
		+	* (+) have tools to deal with
		+	* (-) should write our own parser
		+
		+	XML
		+	* (+) have parsers, even in Eiffel
		+	* (-) no tools for translations
		+
		+	The two possibilities "can" the same things, so I think that we should concentrate on the practical work.
		+
		+	Would you like to write a parser for PO or some tools that can save in XML too?

@@ Line 72: / Line 72: @@
 |- ALIGN="center" bgcolor="#e0e0e0"
-!Total !! 0 !! 5 !!
+!Total !! 0 !! 5 !! 0
 |}
 Despite the votation the file format will still be discussed (with argumentations) at the next meeting. --[[User:Carlo|Carlo]] 22:43, 2 May 2006 (CEST)

@@ Line 50: / Line 50: @@
-{| BORDER="0" CELLPADDING="3" CELLSPACING="0" ID="Table3"
+{| BORDER="1" CELLPADDING="3" CELLSPACING="1" ID="Voting"
 |- ALIGN="center" bgcolor="#e0e0e0"
-! Person!! XML !! PO !! New!!
+! Person!! XML !! PO !! New
 |- ALIGN="center"
-| [[User:Etienner|Etienne]] || || X || ||
+| [[User:Etienner|Etienne]] || || X ||
 |- ALIGN="center"
-| [[User:Vpiff|Vpiff]] || || X || ||
+| [[User:Vpiff|Vpiff]] || || X ||
 |- ALIGN="center"
-| [[User:Murbi|Murbi]] || || X || ||
+| [[User:Murbi|Murbi]] || || X ||
 |- ALIGN="center"
-| [[User:Lücs|Lücs]] || || X || ||
+| [[User:Lücs|Lücs]] || || X ||
 |- ALIGN="center"
-| [[User:Carlo|Carlo]] || || X || ||
+| [[User:Carlo|Carlo]] || || X ||
 <!--Put your vote adding this lines:-->
 <!--|- ALIGN="center"-->
-<!--|Your name || || || ||-->
+<!--|Your name || || ||-->
 <!--with an X on the fileformat that you whant-->
 <!--...And update the Total-->
 |- ALIGN="center" bgcolor="#e0e0e0"
-!Total !! 0 !! 5 !! 0!!
+!Total !! 0 !! 5 !!
 |}
 Despite the votation the file format will still be discussed (with argumentations) at the next meeting. --[[User:Carlo|Carlo]] 22:43, 2 May 2006 (CEST)

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:43, 2 May 2006
Line 72:		Line 72:
	!Total !! 0 !! 4 !! 0!!		!Total !! 0 !! 4 !! 0!!
	\|}		\|}
		+
		+
		+	Despite the votation the file format will still be discussed (with argumentations) at the next meeting. --[[User:Carlo\|Carlo]] 22:43, 2 May 2006 (CEST)